Almost every skylight leak we are called to is not the skylight. It is the flashing around it, or the way the skylight was installed in the first place. We diagnose and repair skylight leaks, replace flashing, and fit replacement units across South Jersey — Waterford Works, Atco, Berlin, Mount Laurel, Glassboro, Hammonton and the surrounding townships.
Caulk is not flashing. This is the single most common thing we find. A skylight is meant to be integrated into the roof with a manufactured flashing kit matched to that model and that roof pitch — a sill piece at the bottom, step flashing up both sides woven into the shingle courses, and a head flashing at the top that takes water around and past the unit. When a skylight is instead bedded in roofing cement or sealed with caulk, it will hold for a few seasons and then fail, because sealant is a consumable and the roof moves with every temperature swing. Re-caulking a leaking skylight buys months. Replacing the flashing properly fixes it.
Is it actually leaking, or is it condensation? Worth establishing before anyone starts work. Condensation forms on the inside face of the glass, runs down evenly, appears in cold weather and gets worse with humidity in the room below — bathrooms and kitchens especially. A leak appears after rain, usually shows at one corner or along one edge, and stains the drywall or the light shaft rather than beading on the glass. The fixes are nothing alike: condensation is a ventilation and insulation problem in the shaft, a leak is a flashing problem on the roof. We check which one you have first.
Fogging between the panes is a different failure again. If the glass looks permanently hazy or there is moisture you cannot wipe away because it is inside the sealed unit, the unit's seal has failed. No amount of flashing work fixes that — the glass assembly itself has to be replaced. On older acrylic dome skylights the equivalent failure is yellowing and crazing, where the plastic has gone brittle under decades of UV and will crack rather than seal.
Repair or replace the unit? Skylight units last roughly twenty to thirty years, so if yours is original to a 1990s roof it is near the end regardless of the leak. The decision usually comes down to this: if the unit is sound and the flashing has failed, we replace the flashing. If the seal has gone, the frame is distorted, or an acrylic dome has gone brittle, replacing the unit is the better money — and the flashing gets renewed as part of that anyway.
The timing that saves you the most money. If you are planning a roof replacement in the next few years and your skylights are twenty-plus years old, replace them at the same time. The flashing, the shingle courses around the opening and the access are all already part of the reroof, so the incremental cost of a new unit is a fraction of what the same job costs as a standalone visit later. Leaving a thirty-year-old skylight in a brand-new roof is the most common avoidable expense we see — it fails two winters later and the new shingles have to be opened back up to deal with it.
Leaks that look like the skylight but are not. Water travels. A stain at the corner of a skylight shaft frequently originates several feet uphill — a split pipe boot, a failed valley, a chimney flashing detail. We trace water to the actual entry point rather than assuming the nearest penetration is the culprit, which is the same approach we take to any roof leak. Where you want the whole roof's condition documented rather than one component, a written roof inspection gives you photographs and a component-by-component assessment.